Broadband Pricing Strategy: The Evolution from Promo Pricing to Price Locks

By Theresa Myers, Manager, and David Young, Vice President – Strategy & Analytics

For decades, the sales strategies of incumbent Internet Service Providers (ISPs) in the US relied on offering an attractive introductory price, followed by rate hikes once the promotional period ended. Customers, attracted by low intro rates, would be required to switch providers if they wished to avoid the rate hike.

This discount-then-hike model has shaped customers’ long-term perceptions. As bills rose, many grew frustrated with what felt like a lack of transparency, leading to lower satisfaction and, ultimately, switching to competitors offering better value.

Now, as broadband market growth slows, ISPs are increasingly turning their attention to churn reduction efforts. Many are rethinking pricing and sales strategies, inspired by the success of 5G fixed wireless services, which are frequently sold without promotional pricing. Instead of perpetuating the promo-based model, providers are shifting toward multi-year price guarantees designed to strengthen trust and improve retention.

The Introduction of Telecom Price Guarantees

Price guarantees, also known as price locks, are agreements in which a provider commits to a fixed service price for a set period of time. These guarantees are offered without requiring a contract, which helps build customer trust – the provider promises consistent pricing while giving customers the freedom to leave at any time if they are not satisfied.

In September 2024, Charter kicked off this movement by announcing its “Customer Commitment,” which provided simplified pricing and performance benefits to customers. In April 2025, Verizon and Comcast followed suit, offering their own multi-year guarantees to their customers.

Introduction of Price Locks by Major US ISPs

CompanyOffer
CharterGuaranteed internet pricing up to three years when bundled with two lines of mobile and/or video service
Verizon3-year price lock on all myPlan and myHome network plans for both new and existing customers
Comcast5-year price guarantee with no annual contract for internet; includes Xfinity’s Wi-Fi gateway and unlimited data

In addition to helping build customer trust and meet evolving expectations, price locks have also helped ISPs differentiate beyond price and speed, increase bundle take up, and reinforce branding.

Extending Guarantees Beyond Pricing

While price locks are becoming more common, they are not the only tactic providers are employing to build customer trust and loyalty. Service level guarantees – once reserved for business customers alone – are rising in popularity for residential customers.

Charter and AT&T are leading the charge, with Charter’s Customer Commitment guaranteeing a full day service credit in the event of an outage lasting over two hours and the AT&T Guarantee offering a full day service credit if a fiber outage lasts over 20 minutes.

These guarantees are shifting customer decision-making from price to service – a trend we expect to continue as the internet market matures.

Working with Cartesian to Ensure your Pricing Approach Remains Competitive

The adoption of price locks and guarantees by major providers is reshaping the residential market, pushing providers of all sizes to rethink their pricing and promotional strategies. Mid-sized ISPs have already begun following suit – for example, TDS Telecom announced all-in pricing in July 2025 – signaling that price simplification is spreading beyond the largest players.

For mid-sized and small ISPs, succeeding in today’s market means evaluating all aspects of attracting and retaining customers – price simplification and consumer guarantees included.

From conjoint analyses to competitive benchmarking and incentive structuring, Cartesian leverages advanced analytics and AI / ML capabilities to help providers in the telecommunications sector meet their goals. With 35 years of experience focused on TMT, Cartesian has the industry knowledge, proven track record, and partnership mindset required to drive pricing strategy.

Contact us today to learn more about Cartesian’s pricing and offer optimization experience.